III. Tolerance, Conflict, and Religious Difference: Historical and Contemporary Issues
Component Leaders: Professors Akeel Bilgrami and Mark Mazower
We at CDTR believe that the current crisis in the area of international
relations, tolerance, and religious conflict has been exacerbated by a
“misreading” of Western Europe’s actual historical experience with religious
conflicts, and the broad range of domestic and international policy patterns
used, in Western Europe and elsewhere, to moderate—or at times to
intensify—these conflicts. CDTR therefore attempts to expand our imaginations
concerning possible new approaches to managing religious conflict in the modern
world by two ambitious projects.
A. Public Lectures and Seminars on “The Theory and History of Tolerance:
Political, Legal and Philosophical Issues”
Leader: Professor Akeel Bilgrami, in collaboration with the
Heyman Center for the Humanities
This project component involves a three year series on “The Theory and
History of Tolerance: Political, Legal and Philosophical Issues” open to the
entire university. During the spring of 2007, six public lectures engage in an
analysis of the Western European tradition of intolerance and tolerance in
religion and politics. In the sixteenth century, different Christian groups were
generally intolerant towards each other, and in most countries, the dominant
political groups were intolerant towards minority religions. A useful
comparative question then is: Given a religious, social, and political context
in which intolerance is the dominant discourse and practice how—if ever—does
tolerance emerge as the dominant discourse and practice?
In 2007/2008, we will then use this background to help us explore these
issues in a comparative perspective, inviting scholars from South Asia, Iran,
Indonesia, and Egypt for an international conference on “Domestic and
International Factors in the Evolution of Practices of Intolerance and
Tolerance”.
In 2008/2009, we will return to the format of public lectures and invite six
speakers to examine the “Effects of Globalization on Issues of Toleration and
the Secular”. Invited speakers will be asked to broadly discuss the strains on
liberal doctrine and practice and the state by looking at phenomena such as:
minority issues in France, Germany, the UK and Scandinavia; problems of
multiculturalism exacerbated by international demographic changes and migrations
of peoples as well as ideas; the travel of human rights ideals, resistance to
such ideals as they travel to the southern hemisphere; their failure to be made
conceptually vernacular for the southern countries; as well as resistance to
human rights ideals by minorities in Europe.
B. Conferences and Creation of an International Faculty/Student Network on
the National and International Management of Religious Minorities in the Ottoman
and Czarist Empires and Their Legacies.
Leader: Mark Mazower, in collaboration with the
Harriman Institute.
Mazower’s most recent book Salonica: Relations of Tolerance among Muslims,
Jews, and Christians from 1450-1950 won wide academic and popular acclaim.
Mazower will create an international network of people and institutions
concerned with the above topic by hosting international conferences on the
“National and International Management of Religious Minorities in the Ottoman
and Czarist Empires” in the fall of 2007 and on “Out of Empire: Trajectories of
Secular Rule, 1920-2005” in the fall of 2008.